View all Archives -
Environment and Development »
Forestry for Sustainable Rural Development
Expansion
As commitment
to community forestry grows, forest departments must develop the
capacity to enlarge upon relatively small-scale activities and to
support much larger programs. The programs that were established
earliest, namely those in India and the Philippines, are now at a
stage where they are expanding to reach larger numbers of people.
Yet expansion—especially rapid expansion—can make even
more acute the structural obstacles to social forestry that
bureaucratic organizations face. As programs grow to encompass
larger geographical areas, the need to respond to a wider variety
of social, ecological, and economic conditions also grows,
intensifying the constraints posed by uniform guidelines and
centrally driven targets. Further, when funds must be disbursed
quickly to a large number of sites, decision making tends to become
more centralized, hindering the agency's flexibility.
In addition,
the effort required to organize activities in a single community
can be extremely demanding on the financial and human resources of
the implementing agency. With rapid expansion, forest departments
are learning that both time and capacity for effective staff
training at the local level often are lacking. Agencies are now
grappling with the challenge of expanding community forestry
programs without sacrificing their essential character: namely, the
capacity to respond to local social and ecological diversity and
the capacity to give adequate attention to
implementation.
Nongovernmental Organizations and
Research Institutions: Their Roles
Working
with Forest-Dependent Communities
NGOs have
often played critical roles in strengthening local institutional
capacity through community organizing, establishing local
organizations, and developing management skills. In addition,
external facilitators have helped ensure representation of
marginalized groups within village organizations. They have also
helped organizations develop methods for managing the forest area
productively and sustainably. In addition, NGOs have assisted local
organizations in negotiations with the government and have provided
a voice for villagers in forums to which they would not otherwise
have access. Related roles have included conflict mediation and the
provision of advocacy and legal services.
Some of these
activities have required improvements in the institutional capacity
of the intermediaries themselves. In the Philippines, a consortium
of NGOs has enhanced the effectiveness of groups working directly
with local communities.